Steve Analysts brilliant myth-busting thread on the last time the government tried a “Red Tape Challenge”, and why any regulatory change is likely to come at an additional cost.


First published in February 2020.

Oh, a Red Tape Challenge.

PMP XTRA
Twitter - @trussliz

It’s not like we could have had one of those in the EU...

Oh wait... we did.

What was that called again?

Oh, yes: The Red Tape Challenge.

It resulted in a LOT of complaints about the Licensing Act and live music, and the main achievements were based on the fact most complaints were not around EU regulation.

The Red Tape Challenge - Achievements. / Gov.uk - Civil Service

Not that there weren’t EU proposals.

The government went to the EU Commission with these proposals and they agreed to fix the issues.

PMP XTRA
Hancock hails boost to economy as UK cuts EU red tape / Gov.uk - Department for Business, Innovation & Skills

The EU have been running a similar campaign called Lighten the Load as part of their ‘Refit’ platform.

It stopped at the end of October 2019, but suggestions are still being taken for a future project ‘Fit for Future’.

The EU Commission have been taking suggestions from people for years. And it looks like they may have got the idea from... our original Red Tape Challenge.

But the Red Tape Challenge in 2011 wasn’t necessarily seen as a success. The response wasn’t that high.

And as the FT article explains, in the 1990s we ran an initiative where trade bodies couldn’t agree.

Sajid Javid to issue ‘Brexit red tape challenge’ to public, 7 Feb 2020. / Financial Times

Now they are faced with arguing for a change which does make the regulation more efficient, but doesn’t cover the additional cost of not having alignment.

This challenge would have been more effective in the EU, where we continued to be aligned, and the changes were made in 27 other countries, rather than at an additional cost. Like the last time we did this.

Already this “Brexit Red Tape Challenge” is inferior to the last one we had in the EU in terms of the fact any regulatory change is likely to come at an additional cost.

So if businesses really want to get together and “make Brexit a success”, they should concentrate on the UK regulation and the gold plating that the UK has done on EU regulation, while not giving them any excuse to make trading conditions harder.


Tweets posted on 6 February 2020 by @EmporersNewC.


PMP XTRA

Check their Voting Record:

🗳️ Liz Truss






Share this article now:





[This piece was first published as a Twitter thread and turned into the above article on 7 February 2020 with the purpose of reaching a larger audience. It has been minorly edited and corrected. | The author of the tweets writes in a personal capacity.]

Creative Commons License
(Cover: Flickr/Department for Business, Innovation and Skills. - 2011 Red Tape Challenge website. / Licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.)