It is a tough path to challenge populism and confront the sham of the Brexit pushers. Disproving false claims takes time, patience, and lots of efforts.
First published in June 2021.
“How to win friends and influence people” was a bestselling book, which among other things advised those who seek popularity to enter into the world of others, praising them, going along with their pet theories and not antagonising them. Applied to politics, it is populism.
I have chosen the opposite direction, but be warned, it is not an easy road. Nowhere do you find more mythology and false beliefs passionately adhered to than in medicine, and the rise of modern scientific or evidence-based medicine out of the darkness of witch-doctoring has been a hard struggle. It is not just that quack cures are profitable; a greater problem is that fake treatments can attract a devoted following and trying to disprove them can provoke hostility.
As well as provoking hostility, disproving false claims takes time and patience, whereas inventing new ones is typically much faster. This was the basis of the “Gish gallop”, defined as “the attempt to overwhelm an opponent by excessive number of arguments, without regard for the accuracy or strength of those arguments.” It was a debating technique originally used by creationists arguing against evolution, and later adopted by Brexiters.
In my own field of psychiatry, conventional advice has always been that to attempt to argue with an irrational belief, or delusion, is futile. Indeed, in the old days of the asylums, staff would sometimes dress up in costumes to indulge the beliefs of someone who believed he was, say, master of the universe. Or these days, I suppose the title might be Emperor of Global Britain. Thus it was that Keir Starmer advised his close associates “do not mention Brexit, or if you have to, say you agree with it.”
My research into olfaction gave me direct experience of the problem of challenging falsehoods. Talking about the evocative power of smell had stimulated much positive interest from the media, but when I ventured to question – even tentatively – the more far-fetched claims of aromatherapists to cure specific diseases, I found myself boycotted by the aromatherapy community.
In many ways, Brexit ideology is another cult, following in the footsteps of Lysenkoism in Russia, and the Moonies and Scientology in America, and based fundamentally on deception, but I will address this theme in a future article. Towering figures who have devoted their careers to laying bare deception and trickery include James Randi in the USA and Richard Dawkins in this country.
Randi, who challenged the spoon-bending abilities of Uri Geller and the supernatural powers of self professed psychics, noted that proving these people were frauds could actually increase the faith of true believers. Something similar has been observed with Trump and Johnson. It is not an easy road.
Professor Richard Dawkins of Oxford University, whose book “The God Delusion” boldly explored the shortcomings of religion, was well aware of the power of faith. But Chris Grey, another incisive thinker and author of an acclaimed blog on Brexit, argues that with Brexiters it is not simply a matter of faith in their ideology, but that “they have developed a form of reasoning which is impervious to reason. So when adverse effects cannot be denied, they are re-cast so as to prove Brexit was right... There’s every sign now that our country is going to disappear down this rabbit hole of illogic, compounded by delusional ideas.”
Randi and Dawkins have faced much abuse in return for their efforts, but earned a certain respect. I too have lost longstanding friends who voted Leave, but retained my self respect.
Today we have a choice: we can live happily in cloud cuckoo land, or we can confront the sham of the Brexit pushers.
- Gish Gallop | Wikipedia
- Labour MPs bewildered at party's orders to remain silent on Brexit | The New European
- Lysenkoism | BBC Radio 4
- James Randi, Magician Who Debunked Paranormal Claims, Dies at 92 | New York Times
- Richard Dawkins | Britannica
— AUTHOR —
▫ John King, Retired doctor & Remain campaigner.
GET THEM INVOLVED:
[This piece was first published in PMP Magazine on 8 June 2021. | The author writes in a personal capacity.]
(Cover: Bath For Europe. / Licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.)